‹ View All Insights

How Age Based Asset Allocation Can Leave Money On The Table…

Published by Daniel Messeca, CFP on Thu, Jul 16, 2020
We believe that age is one factor among many to consider.

There are many factors to consider when determining your investment strategy.

How do you incorporate your age into determining your investment allocation?

Do you subscribe to the 100 minus your age theory for how to determine the stock-to-bond mix?  Or perhaps you are using a target date fund that automatically gets more conservative as you get closer to retirement?

Whether you follow investment strategies or not, many investors believe that as they get older, their portfolios should get more defensive. “Given my age…” is a phrase I hear a lot as I work with clients and prospects. Surprise! Age alone should not determine the way you invest.

The truth is…while your age may be a significant factor in the portfolio allocations we recommend, it usually is just one of many factors we consider when recommending Personal Portfolio allocations to our clients. Depending on your specific financial circumstances, sometimes age plays a minimal role, or is not a factor at all.

We believe that following asset allocation models based on age alone could result in overly conservative portfolios. If you are following a conservative investment strategy (e.g., generally a large allocation to bonds) when your circumstances point towards greater risk tolerance and capacity, you could be leaving money on the table – and who wants that?

Broadly speaking, there are two additional factors to consider as you build the right investment plan for yourself and your family. These may be just as important – and often more important – to consider than your age.

We believe that balancing your asset allocation by age and risk tolerance should give you a better chance at continuing to grow to retirement and beyond.

Capacity For Risk In Your Asset Allocation

Your risk capacity for any given account speaks mainly to your short term and long term financial needs. You may have different risk capacities for different accounts.

If you need to start pulling money out of an account next year, it may have a lower capacity for risk compared to an account you don’t plan to touch for another 10 years. The longer the time horizon for a particular account, the more aggressive you can be.

The sooner you need money, and the more dependent you are on the portfolio, the lower your capacity for risk in that account. You would need to protect funds designated for the short term, because you know you’ll be accessing them soon.

Conversely, the longer you can wait to access your funds, and the less dependent you are on the portfolio, the more aggressive you can be.

Perhaps you are 65 or 70, but you are still working or perhaps even running your own business. Maybe you are passionate about your work and have no plans to retire any time soon. In this case, age may indeed be “just a number” as you may not need to access the funds in your portfolio for some time.

Tolerance For Risk Should Affect Your Portfolio

Your risk tolerance speaks to your emotional reaction to portfolio fluctuation.

If you would likely sell after a 10% market drop, you have a lower risk tolerance than if you would have held. On the other hand, if you would consider buying after a 10% market drop, you have a higher risk tolerance.

Your overall tolerance for risk is an important factor to understand for a healthy, wealth-building financial strategy.

The good news is that your tolerance for risk can vary by account. You can be conservative with some accounts and aggressive with others. However, investing more aggressively than your comfort level could lead to shifting investment strategies at the wrong time, thereby potentially compounding locked-in-losses. On the other hand, investing more conservatively based solely on age could mean you are missing out on potential growth.

Are You Using The Right Investment Strategies?

Your portfolio should strategically evolve as you get older. While it may happen that your capacity and tolerance change as you age, it is not your age alone that impacts those decisions.

Here are just a few reasons for keeping your foot on the gas into your 60s, 70s, 80s and beyond:

  1. You are investing for the next generation.
  2. Your income sources cover your living expenses.
  3. You over-saved (congratulations!) and your distributions make up a very small percentage of your portfolio.

If your portfolio is based solely on age based asset allocation, and not factoring in risk capacity and risk tolerance, you could be giving up the potential for more growth in your account. 

Wealth can be created, or destroyed, based on how well your true capacity and tolerance is aligned with your account allocation. Reflecting on your emotions and any financial changes you may have made over the last few months is a good starting point for reevaluating. Even for the most risk tolerant, some angst is normal.

Risk is not a zero-sum game. It’s strategic.


This message is provided for informational purposes only, reflects our general views on investing, and should not be relied upon as recommendations or financial planning advice. We encourage you to seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding all personal finance issues.

Access to Motley Fool Wealth Management (“MFWM”) is only available to clients pursuant to an Investment Advisory Agreement and acceptance of our Client Relationship Summary (PDF) and MFWM's Brochure (PDF - 204 KB). You are encouraged to read these documents carefully. All investments involve risk and may lose money. MFWM does not guarantee the results of any of its advice or account management. Clients should be aware that their individual account results may not exactly match the performance of any of our Model Portfolios. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Each Personal Portfolio is subject to an account minimum, which varies based on the strategies included in the portfolio. MFWM retains the right to revise or modify portfolios and strategies if it believes such modifications would be in the best interests of its clients.

During discussions with our Certified Financial Planners, they may provide advice with respect to 401(k) rollovers into accounts that are managed by MFWM.   Such recommendations pose potential conflicts of interest in that rolling retirement savings into a MFWM managed account will generate ongoing asset-based fees for MFWM that it would not otherwise receive.